Difference and Similarities between Catholics and Lutherans
Catholics and Lutherans have some fundamental differences in their beliefs, but they also share some key similarities. Both are the most prominent branches of the Christian religion. So what are the main differences between these two Christian denominations?
Well, Catholics trace their faith back to the apostle Peter, whereas Lutherans claim Martin Luther as their spiritual father. Catholics adhere to the teachings of the Pope, while Lutherans do not recognize the authority of the Pope. Catholics practice transubstantiation, which is the belief that the bread and wine used in Communion become the actual body and blood of Jesus Christ, while Lutherans believe that Christ is present in the elements but do not believe in transubstantiation.
That’s just a snapshot of some of the key differences between Catholics and Lutherans. For a more detailed look at these two faiths, keep reading.
What Is the Catholic Church?
The Catholic Church is one of the oldest and foremost Christian organizations in the world. It’s based on the teachings of Jesus Christ, who, according to the Bible, founded the church in Jerusalem.
The Church’s leader is the successor of the Apostle Peter who is the Bishop of Rome, otherwise called Pope. Jesus Christ appointed Peter to be the leader of the church and this leadership has been passed down from generations to generations till date, and the current Pope is the successor of the Apostle Peter.
The Catholic Church recognizes seven sacraments: baptism, confirmation, eucharist, confession, marriage, holy orders, and anointing of the sick. Catholics also believe in the Holy Trinity :God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
The Catholic Church has a hierarchy of bishops, priests, and laity. Bishops are in charge of dioceses, which are subdivisions of a country or region. Priests are responsible for ministering to Catholics in their local area. Laity includes everyone else who isn’t a bishop or priest.
What Is the Lutheran Church?
What is the Lutheran Church? The Lutheran Church, officially known as the Evangelical Lutheran Church in America, is a Protestant Christian denomination that was founded in the early 16th century by Martin Luther.
Martin Luther is a German friar in the Augustinian order known as the “Father of the Reformation.”. He was a Bible scholar and Professor of Bible at University of Wittenberg. He rejected the idea that the teachings of the Pope carried the same weight as the Bible and said that the Catholic Church has strayed from the scriptures.
Luther initially didn’t want to start a new denomination, he wanted to reform the Catholic Church but Rome held that the office of Pope had been established by Jesus Christ and that the Pope served as Christ’s vicar, or representative, on earth. Therefore, the Catholic church rejected any attempts to limit the role of the Pope or cardinals.
The five major principles of the Reformation are Called “five solas” (“sola” meaning “alone”):
1.Sola fidei: faith alone; salvation is only based on faith alone, not faith and
2.Sola gratia: grace alone; salvation only depends on God’s grace, and not
on good works.
3.Sol scriptura: Scripture alone; tradition isn’t unimportant, but the Bible is
4.Soli Deo: glory to God alone; neither the Church nor Mary should share in the
glory for salvation.
5.Solus Christus: Christ alone; only Jesus can save, as opposed to other
biblical or church figures.
Due to the failure of reforming the Catholic Church, in the year 1521, Martin Luther and his followers split from the Catholic Church becoming the first Protestants. The Protestant church was called LUTHERAN.
Martin Luther never liked the name Lutheran, rather supported the name Evangelical meaning ‘Good news’.
The term Lutheran was kept by a German Theologian Dr. Johann Maier von Eck.
The faith of Lutherans is based out of doctrines laid out by Martin Luther.In the year 1625, the first Lutheran Church was set up.
Lutherans believe that the Bible is the authoritative source of all religious knowledge, and they emphasize the importance of preaching and teaching the Scriptures. They also believe in the doctrine of justification by faith alone, which holds that salvation is granted to sinners by God’s grace alone, through faith in Jesus Christ.
Compared to Catholics, Lutherans place a greater emphasis on individual autonomy and on the priesthood of all believers. They also teach that the sacraments are not necessary for salvation, and that salvation can be achieved through faith alone.
What Are the Origins of the Catholic and Lutheran Churches?
Catholics trace their church back to Jesus and his apostles. In fact, the Catholic Church is the oldest institution in the world. It was founded in AD 28 by St. Peter, who was the first bishop of Rome.
Lutherans, on the other hand, trace their church back to Martin Luther, who was an important figure in the Protestant Reformation. Lutherans separated from the Catholic Church in the 16th century, and they have their own set of beliefs and practices.
What Are the Main Differences Between Catholics and Lutherans?
When it comes to the core beliefs of Catholics and Lutherans, there are a few key differences.
Catholics believe that salvation comes through faith and good works, while Lutherans believe that it comes through faith alone. Catholics also believe in the sacraments, which are rituals that bring about grace and has seven Sacraments which are Baptism, Confirmation, Holy Eucharist, Penance, Anointing of the sick, Holy Orders, Marriage. While Lutherans generally don’t believe in the sacraments as channels of divine grace and also believe in two Sacraments Baptism and Lords supper.
Catholics also hold to the doctrine of the Trinity, while Lutherans accept the doctrine of the Trinity but also emphasize free will. Finally, Catholics teach that Mary is the Mother of God and queen of heaven and that she can be prayed to so that she can intercede for us and should be honored, while Lutherans do not have much regards to Mary and doesn’t believe she can interceed for people, they believe only God should be prayed to.
Lutherans believe that Christ is the leader of the church and that Pope shouldn’t have divine authority over the people, Catholics in the other hand believe that Christ granted supreme authority to the Pope who’s the successor of the Apostle Peter.
The Catholic Church believe there’s Purgatory where souls that died with menial sins go and suffer for a while before going to heaven, while Lutherans believe there’s no such thing as purgatory, only heaven and hell.
Unlike Catholics that has hierarchy of Priests, whereby priests with higher ranks have power over the lower ones, Lutherans believe that each church should be governed locally not by centralized authority. Although Lutherans have bishops, they don’t exercise same authority over members like the Catholic Bishops. Lutheran not having centralized leadership has caused the church to split apart in recent decades due to definition of marriage, gender related issues, adoption of modern theology and social sensibilities, etc.
Catholics believe in transubstantiation of the communion into the true body and blood of Jesus Christ during the mass, while Lutherans believe that the bread and wine are just a symbol, Catholics also practice Close Communion which is only qualified Catholics can take holy communion, while Lutherans practice Open Communion that’s anyone can take communion.
Lutherans believe that the Bible is the only guide for Christians and follows only what’s in the bible, while Catholics believe both the Bible and the church traditions are important and both should be followed.
Catholic Bible has 73 books while Lutherans bible has 66 books.
What Are Some Similarities Between Catholics and Lutherans?
Catholics and Lutherans have a lot in common. For starters, they both follow the Bible as their guide. They also both recognize Jesus as their savior and believe in holy trinity.
They both say the Nicene and Apostle Creeds.
Both have Sacraments.
Both Catholic and Lutheran has same root.
Catholics and Lutherans have some fundamental differences in their beliefs, but they also share some similarities.
Catholics and Lutherans both trace their origins back to the early days of Christianity. Catholics believe that the Church was founded by Jesus Christ and that it has been passed down through the ages through apostles and bishops. Lutherans believe that the Church was founded by Jesus Christ, but that it has been distorted over time. They trace their roots back to Martin Luther, who broke away from the Catholic Church in the 16th century.
Catholics and Lutherans have some fundamental differences in their beliefs. Catholics believe in the virgin birth and in transubstantiation, which means that they believe that when they eat communion bread and wine, they are eating the actual body and blood of Jesus Christ. Lutherans do not believe in transubstantiation, but they do believe in Jesus Christ’s real presence in the bread and wine.
Despite these differences, Catholics and Lutherans share some similarities. Both faiths place a strong emphasis on faith and grace, and on reading the Bible as a guide to living a good life. Both faiths also have a strong sense of community, with rituals and traditions that bring people together.